WP 546 Assessing decentralised policy implementation in Vietnam. The case of land recovery and resettlement in the Vung Ang Economic Zone / by J. de Wit ... [et al.]
ISS Working Paper by Joop de Wit, Luong Viet Sang, Le Van Chien, Luong Thu Hien, Ha Viet Hung, Dang Thi Anh Tuyet, Dao Ngoc Bau, Quang Hoa and Mai Thi Thanh Tam.
Abstract
From 2006 plans were implemented to create a deep-sea water port linked to an Economic Zone in the coastal Province of Ha Tinh, located in north central Vietnam. The multi-purpose Zone entitled ‘Vung Ang’, was to attract foreign investors, while the port would provide a link to nearby Laos and Thailand.
The project obviously had large implications for the administrations at various levels of governance from Hanoi to the coastal communes and villages, but even more serious impacts on the people living in the affected areas. A large area of about 23,000 hectares was to be cleared, affecting the people of 9 communes, in some of which all inhabitants had to leave their houses and homesteads, to be relocated to completely new settlements about 10 miles inland. These tightly knit communities were not too happy with the prospect to leave their homes and land, the burial places of their ancestors, and the long term comforts of community support networks.
While initial decision making process started at the highest levels of Vietnam Governance, the implementation of port and industrial park construction and the related relocation policy was delegated to Ha Tinh province, which is consistent with current decentralisation policies in Vietnam. Actual implementation was carried out by the affected District and Commune level officials – with support from the Communist Party led Mass Organisations – who were in charge of the planning and implementation of the relocation process. This entailed a complex and sensitive series of steps to inform affected households, prepare relocation areas and allocate compensation and alternative housing.
This paper describes the implementation dynamics of relocation by depicting and assessing the roles of all stakeholders involved, including the impacts – for better or for worse – of the relocated households. It brings out the way local authorities dealt with affected people, including efforts linked to the ideal of grass-roots democracy. Key areas of contestation are uncovered, such as inadequate infrastructure and low compensation rates. The paper has a second objective to assess the degree to which decentralisation in Vietnam has been actually implemented, and how this affects policy making processes such as the Vung Ang port/industrial zone project.
The paper concludes that the relocation policy was implemented in a fairly efficient and harmonious way – with a very intensive engagement of the entire provincial administrative machinery, but that it is too early to assess the livelihood opportunities of the relocated households.
Keywords: Vietnam, decentralisation, land acquisition and compensation policy, livelihoods
About the authors
| |
Dr. Joop de Wit is a social anthropologist (PhD Free University Amsterdam, 1993) teaching as Senior Lecturer Public Policy and Development Management at the International Institute of Social Studies (ISS) of Erasmus University. His regional interest is in Asia (India, Vietnam and Indonesia). His publications include books, articles and chapters on his key research interests of urban poverty alleviation, urban (local) governance and politics, decentralization, and community dynamics and (informal) community-government interfaces. At ISS, Joop de Wit is a member of the ISS Major Program Governance, Policy and Political Economy, and of two specialisation tracks: ‘Public Policy and Management’ and ‘Local Development Strategies’. He leads courses on ‘Local Governance, Politics and Management’ and ‘States, Societies and the Politics of Development’, and is engaged in other courses both at ISS and as part of capacity development projects in various developing countries. | |
|
|
Dr. Luong Viet Sang, Dr. Le Van Chien, Dr. Luong Thu Hien, Dr. Ha Viet Hung, Dr. Dang Thi Anh Tuyet, Dr. Dao Ngoc Bau, Dr. Quang Hoa and Dr. Mai Thi Thanh Tam are all working as lecturers and researchers in different institutes of the Ho Chi Minh Academy of Politics and Public Administration based in Hanoi (Institutes of State and Law, Economics, Sociology, Political Science and Philosophy). The Ho Chi Minh Academy is one of Vietnam’s leading research and teaching institutions, which trains the high-ranking leadership of the Party, the Government administration and the Mass Organizations, while providing the teaching curriculum for a network of 63 Provincial Political Schools at the provincial level. The Academy also conducts interdisciplinary studies in the fields of social studies and public administration, contributing to policy recommendations for managing socio–economic development in Vietnam. | |
ISS Working Paper Series
Complete list of ISS Working Papers
Subscribe to our free email notification service for the ISS Working Paper Series
Publication date: Monday, 16 July 2012
