Responding to mortality: on evasive, destructive, and constructive responses—Thoughts from Becker, Fromm and Nussbaum

We are pleased to alert you to ISS working paper 737, Responding to mortality: on evasive, destructive, and constructive responses—Thoughts from Becker, Fromm and Nussbaum, by Des Gasper.

Abstract                          

While preoccupied with mortality, his own and that of close family members, the poet John Keats coined the term negative capability, ability to live with ‘uncertainties, mysteries and doubts’. The paper looks at this and other senses of ‘negative capability’, including constructive and destructive responses to challenges and adversity, and the negating of self in order to be more attentive to others. It especially explores responses to the prospect and certainty of death, including relevant internal capabilities and the apparent and surprising relative neglect of these issues in the human development and capability approach literatures, exceptions being the work of Martha Nussbaum and some human studies. That neglect is possibly part of a broader relative weakness in attention to internal capabilities for response to adversity. After documenting these relative gaps, the paper examines a range of responses to mortality and death, including fear, denial, evasion, possible destructive energies including for the death of others or of oneself, reflection, acceptance, solidarity with others, and ‘immortality projects’ by which we seek to influence others beyond our death and perhaps to be remembered. It looks in detail at work by Nussbaum, by the philosophical anthropologist Ernest Becker on ‘the denial of death’ and its destructive potential results, and by the social psychologist Erich Fromm on human destructiveness and the alternative of ‘biophilia’, affection for all life. It proposes serious attention by human development and capability scholars to these issues in the same way as issues of childhood have received, including, for example, attention to the moulding of consciousness of legacy and of commitment to one’s successors.

Keywords

Mortality, death, capability approach, negative capability, internal capabilities, Martha Nussbaum, Ernest Becker, Erich Fromm.

Click here to access this working paper

Compare 0 study programme